The state-owned Coal India Limited (CIL) experienced a rough market debut for its Q2 earnings on October 28, with shares falling over 5% in morning trades following a disappointing quarterly performance. The coal mining giant reported a 22% year-on-year drop in consolidated net profit, which stood at Rs 6,274.8 crore for the quarter ending September 2024, down from Rs 8,048.64 crore in the corresponding period last year. The company’s revenue also saw a decline, slipping to Rs 32,177.92 crore from Rs 34,760.3 crore in the prior year quarter, largely due to reduced coal demand, market pressures, and intensified competition.
Coal India’s revenue contraction and profit decline are attributed to weak power demand, adverse weather conditions like heavy rainfall affecting mining operations, and increased competition. These factors weighed heavily on the company’s profitability, leading to a year-on-year (YoY) EBITDA decline of approximately 20%. According to a report by Nuvama Institutional Equities, the company’s performance was further impacted by softened coal prices and stagnant sales volume growth, which only rose by 1% during the first half of FY25.Agra Stock
Nuvama also highlighted that Coal India plans to increase volumes through e-auctions. However, should this shift happen, it could further depress prices. The brokerage maintains a “hold” rating on Coal India, reducing its target price from Rs 542 to Rs 517, given the company’s short-term challenges.Jaipur Wealth Management
Despite the current headwinds, Coal India has ambitious capital expenditure plans, projecting annual capex of Rs 15,000-20,000 crore for the next four to five years. Around 40% of this expenditure will be directed toward non-coal initiatives, including thermal and solar power plants, coal gasification projects, and fertilizer plants. The company anticipates that returns on these investments will materialize over the next four to five years, potentially boosting its revenue diversification and sustainability goals. However, Nuvama warns that these ventures may impact Coal India’s return ratios in the near term.
Meanwhile, Emkay Global has a more optimistic stance, maintaining a “buy” rating with a target price of Rs 600. The brokerage expects a potential recovery in the second half of FY25 and believes Coal India remains a strategic player in India’s energy mix. Emkay Global asserts that the country’s energy demand will continue to rely heavily on coal, and Coal India’s role in meeting these demands will sustain its position as a key energy providerHyderabad Investment. Emkay further projects that Coal India’s volume growth could be supported by a revival in thermal power capex, aligning with India’s forecasted coal requirement increase of 400-450 million tonnes over the next 6-7 years.
PhilipCapital echoes Emkay’s optimism, noting that Coal India is poised to supply the bulk of the increased coal demand. The brokerage maintains a “buy” rating with a higher target price of ₹605, assigning equal weight to EV/EBITDA and PE ratios and citing the company’s potential to sustain a high-single to low-double-digit volume CAGR in the medium term. PhilipCapital has slightly adjusted its FY25/FY26 volume projections, reducing them by 3% due to lower offtakes in the first half of FY25.
In addition to its earnings report, Coal India announced an interim dividend of Rs 15.75 per share for FY2024-25, payable on November 24, with a record date set for November 5, 2024. This dividend distribution signals the company’s commitment to rewarding shareholders amid recent stock volatilityUdabur Wealth Management. Despite short-term market corrections, the dividend may appeal to long-term investors seeking steady income.
Following the earnings announcement, Coal India shares traded at Rs 439.2 on the NSE as of 10 am, marking a 4.75% decrease from the previous day’s closing price. Over the past two weeks, the stock has declined by 6.46%, down 8.73% over the last month, reflecting broader market challenges and the coal sector’s susceptibility to seasonal and cyclical pressures.
Nonetheless, on a year-to-date (YTD) basis, Coal India’s stock has demonstrated resilience, rising 20.78% due to strong first-quarter performance. Over the past three years, the stock has surged by 164.88%, with a five-year gain of 124.08%.
In another move, Coal India has announced plans to exit its wholly-owned subsidiary, CIL Solar PV Limited (CSPL), which was established to explore solar sector opportunities. The decision comes in light of competitive pressures from established solar players and regulatory challenges, particularly regarding restrictions on imported solar technology. The company’s regulatory filing specifies an 8-10 month period to complete the exit process.
Coal India’s departure from the solar sector highlights the high entry barriers for new players in an increasingly competitive market. The company will continue to explore non-coal investments under its capex plan, aiming to mitigate long-term risks while addressing India’s growing energy demands.
Chennai Stock